Who really controls American electricity prices?

Austin, Texas – 18. August: View of the electricity visit next to overlooked on the highway 18. August 2023. in Austin, Texas. The Electric Reliability Council (Ercot) was looking for Texas to preserve the government because the extended heat wave continues cleaning by the state. Today, marks 42 consecutive days of three-digit time in the state. (Photo Brandon Bell / Getty Images

Getti images

When we see prices and falls to the gas pump, we mostly have an idea of ​​what changes changes. In general, these are the movements in the base price of oil, or sometimes there are refinery problems that can affect gas stations even when oil prices are stable. And people mostly blame in oil companies in any case.

Electricity markets are far more opaque. Electricial bills jumped in many places this summer, but the reasons you hear are dependent on which you ask.

The politicians of the climate mandate curve, communal services point to the infrastructure upgrades and analysts of natural gas volatility. The truth is far mesa and more complex than a gas supply chain. Prices are a formatted chain of fuel suppliers, generators, grid, regulators and investors – each adding its own costs, incentives and risks.

In a system built to be competitive and transparent, a big question is: Who really controls American electricity prices?

Multi-Saliced ​​Machine

It is true that electricity prices do not set an authority. They are the outcome of the chain of events in which they cost through a few hands before they reach your monthly account.

Fuel providers – Invisible hand

Natural gas, coal, uranium and renewable sources Basic price for generation. When gas prices usually follow – due to weather conditions, geopolitics or cost of demand and exports. Even in renewable sources – heavy regions, Gas often sets the marginal price It cleans the market.

Electricity generators – Bidmakers

Independent electricity manufacturers (IPP) and plant ownership plants Offer in wholesale markets. Their factor offer in fuel, maintenance and desired return. In the competitive regions, generators live or die at the market price. However, it was a very lucrative market for many competitive producers in recent years. In regulated states, the price plus plus still protect many plants from direct swings.

Grid Operators – Market Architects

Regional Transmission Organizations (RTOS) like PJM, Ercot and Caiso Run Markets for everyday and in real time. They are shipping the lowest cost power first, manage congestion and maintain reliability. Their location algorithms of marginal prices can dramatically jump prices when they are limited by vast or transmission lines.

Utility – Delivery layer

Support programs buy wholesale power and deliver it to homes and enterprises. In regulated countries, they recover costs through cases submitted to state commissions. They act more as intermediaries in deregulated markets, passing through market prices with a limited label.

Regulators – doors

State communal commissions approve rates, capital recovery plans and return allowed. They can slow down mountaineers, but they rarely block them directly if they are attached to fuel or infrastructure costs. At the federal level, the Federal Regulatory Commission for Energy (FERC) oversees interstate transmission and wholesale rules.

Investors – hidden influences

Shareholders expect constant dividends and predictable returns. Their pressure shapes capital distribution, design assessment and project – often tilting utility services according to capital intensive projects guarantee recovery, even when there are cheaper solutions.

Why do prices swing

Electricity prices are fitted for instability, and drivers go via seasonal demand.

Fuel costs

Natural gas still sets the marginal price on most American markets. The cold in a new English or Texas heat wave can send prices to jump within hours.

Time

The climate now push the grid in its boundaries more often. In markets such as Ercot, scarcity mechanisms can start massive spikes even during a short lack of supply.

Infrastructure bottlenecks

Configuring transmission and limited interregional connection isolate some markets. Prices of congestion can push local prices even when the generation is abundant elsewhere.

Policy design

Capacity markets, carbon prices and renewable mandates that all affect how generators offer and How do utilities recover costs. Policies intended to accelerate decarbonization can raise almost time costs before long-term savings materialize.

Market structure

Vertically integrated utilities offer a more stable price, but the competition is lacking. Retail markets submit competition – but they also exhibit consumers to wholesale swings swings, often without effective protection tools.

Together, these factors create a price system that is reactive, fragmented and difficult to predict. For investors, understanding these drivers are crucial – not only for choosing utility supplies, but also for predicting regulatory and infrastructural shifts.

Case studies in the form of pricing

Electricity markets reveal their true character under stress. These three regions show how market design and fuel dependence create very different outcomes.

Texas (Ercot): The price of scarcity meets deregulation.

Winter storm Uri in 2021. exposed Ercot’s vulnerabilities. With minimal interconnections to other countries and without a capacity market, Ercot relied on the prices of scarcity to maintain a generation online. Wholesale prices pointed to 9,000 USD / MWHBanking dozens of retail providers and leaving consumers with retroactive charges. Investors in the flexible asset generations wanted profit for windows. The deputies have been proposed by the proposed reform since then, but the basic compromise between the freedom of market and reliability remains.

California (Caiso): Reconstruction, views, fire and risk premiums.

California Aggressive renewable construction creates a unique price dynamics. Middle minor surpluses are often pushed Wholesale prices negativeIt’s just that prices jump during the evening ramp. Adding Forgets for Wildfire-PG & E 2019 Bankruptcy is a major example – and some of the biggest retail rates in the nation are the result. Programs to respond to demand and use speeds in order to apply the target for ironing peaks, but instability still exists. Investors see innovation here, but they must accept higher regulatory and climate risk.

New England (ISO-No): Pipeline restrictions and winter spikes.

Despite progressive energy policies, Nova England is still very dependent on natural gas in winter. The limited pipeline capacity forces the region to import LNG in global prices, which can be spread during the cold. The ISO-NO capacity market offers some buffer, but Group shocks are still happening. In January 2022. years, wholesale prices were briefly crossed $ 200 / MVH despite an adequate generation that shows that fuel logistics, and not generation capacity, can be a limited limit.

Winners and Losers

The price of electricity is not only about cost recovery; It is a transfer of value between stakeholders.

Utilities often come forward. In regulated states earn guaranteed returns on capital projects – whether it is upgrading transmission, networking of a network or smart meter. In deregulated markets continue to collect shipping fees and benefit from ownership in infrastructure.

Independent electricity producers can benefit well from instability. Pircle gas gains, flexible generation and more and more storage means recording premium price when supplying.

Infrastructure investors – including pension funds and private capital-quietly collect tenarism from transmission lines, substations and renewable portfolio sources. Their returnees are often associated with inflation, paid by a war who cannot understand where their money goes.

Meanwhile, consumers match ter from volatility. Households have little ability to protect themselves, leaving them vulnerable to bumps of fuel and politics. The large industrial industry is better, using production on site, from demand responses and long-term contracts for exposure.

Kimodori Kimpaker must balance favorable, reliability and decarbony. When background fire or infrastructure reforms are lagging, they pay a political price.

In short, the price of electricity is less about electrons and more about the distribution. Investors who invite an asset that can be compensated for the speed and standing of the eligible generation that can be adhered to. For all others, forces set prices are largely invisible – and often inconsistent budget of households.

The illusion of control

It is tempting that electricity prices are simply a product of supply and demand, but reality is far choreographed. From the fuel market to the regulator, the system is layered and opaque. Consumers think they pay power; In reality, they finance infrastructural projects, policy objectives and investors.

For investors, the lesson is clear: the winners are those who understand choreography – choreographic assets with the guaranteed cost recovery, envisages regulatory turn and volatility fence. For all other prices power is a movable target.

Electricity prices are not dictated. They are negotiated. And there are a lot of parties at the table.